
My Daughter’s Teacher Refused to Paint Her Face Like the Other Girls, but What She Said to My Little Girl Broke My Heart!!
My daughter woke me up at five-forty on the morning of her first school festival. She came padding into our bedroom in her purple unicorn pajamas, climbed up onto the bed, and sat on my stomach with her whole weight, which at six years old is about forty-two pounds of pure determination.
“Mommy,” she whispered, two inches from my face. “It’s festival day.”
“It’s still dark, baby,” I mumbled.
“Festival day,” she said again, louder, as if I hadn’t understood. “There’s face painting, Mommy. Kenzie says there’s face painting and a bouncy castle and a cakewalk. I want a butterfly.”
I opened one eye. Victoria was grinning at me in the gray light from the window, that enormous, whole-face grin that pushes her cheeks up so high her almond-shaped eyes nearly disappear. My husband, Chris, groaned beside me and pulled his pillow over his head.
“A butterfly,” I said. “What color?”
She thought about it very seriously.
“Pink,” she said. “And purple. And sparkly.”
She’d been talking about the Fall Festival at Brookside Elementary for a week. Every afternoon when I picked her up, it was the first thing out of her mouth. The bouncy castle, the cakewalk, the hay bales by the playground, the face painting. Her teacher had sent home a flyer with a picture of a pumpkin on it, and Victoria had taped it to the refrigerator herself, crookedly, with about forty pieces of tape.
I got her dressed in her favorite outfit, purple leggings and a pink sweater with a sequin heart on the front that changes color when you brush it with your hand. I brushed her fine brown hair into two little pigtails with purple bows. She wanted her sparkly sneakers, the ones that light up when she stomps. She stomped all the way to the car.
At the school, at eight-thirty, I walked her to the side entrance where the first graders gathered. The parking lot was full of cars and the playground was already set up with hay bales and orange balloons tied to the fence. Parents were carrying in folding tables and crockpots for the chili lunch. I could see the big inflatable castle being blown up on the soccer field, slumping and rising like something breathing.
I knelt down in front of Victoria at the door. She was practically vibrating.
“Be good,” I said. “Have so much fun. Get your butterfly.”
“Pink and purple and sparkly,” she said.
“Pink and purple and sparkly.” I kissed her forehead.
She threw her arms around my neck and squeezed, hard, the way she always does, with her whole body. Then she let go and ran inside with her pigtails bouncing and her sneakers lighting up, and she didn’t look back. She never looks back. That’s one of the things I love most about her.
Everything seemed perfectly normal.
I drove to work. I’m a makeup artist and wig designer at the Indiana Repertory Theatre in downtown Indianapolis, and that week we were in tech rehearsals for *A Christmas Carol*, which meant sixty actors and a hundred and forty costume changes and my hands full of latex and spirit gum from nine in the morning until midnight. I was in the makeup room at the theater, gluing a false nose onto the actor who plays Scrooge, when my phone rang.
It was an hour and ten minutes after I’d dropped her off. The screen said Brookside Elementary.
“Mrs. Parker?” A woman’s voice. Calm, but careful. “This is Diane Whitaker. The principal at Brookside.”
“Is Victoria all right?”
“She’s safe,” Mrs. Whitaker said quickly. “She’s not hurt. But she’s been crying for about twenty minutes, and she keeps asking us to call you. She won’t stop. She says she wants to go home.” She paused. “Could you come pick her up?”
“What happened?”
Another pause. A longer one.
“She’s very upset,” Mrs. Whitaker said. “She hasn’t been able to tell us exactly. I think it would help if you came.”
I was already grabbing my car keys. I left the Scrooge actor sitting in my chair with half a nose.
## Chapter Two: Victoria
My daughter, Victoria, has Down syndrome.
We found out when I was twenty weeks pregnant. A doctor in a small, cold room at St. Vincent Hospital in Indianapolis showed us the numbers from the blood test and the ultrasound and used the word “abnormality” four times in ten minutes. Chris held my hand so hard it hurt. On the drive home, neither of us said a word for forty minutes. Then, at a stoplight on Keystone Avenue, Chris looked over at me and said, “She’s ours. That’s the only thing I need to know.”
She was born on a snowy morning in February, six years and eight months before that festival. Six pounds, eleven ounces. She had a heart defect, a small hole between the chambers, that needed surgery when she was five months old at Riley Children’s Hospital. She spent nine days in the cardiac ICU with tubes and wires everywhere, and I slept in a chair beside her and memorized every beep of every machine.
She came home. She grew. She rolled over late and sat up late and walked at twenty-two months, holding Chris’s fingers, across our living room in Carmel, Indiana, while I cried and filmed it on my phone. She talked late too. Her first word was “mama.” Her second was “more.” Her third was “no.” She has never once since then been shy about any of them.
She is the most joyful person I have ever known. She hugs strangers in the grocery store. She dances to the music in the dentist’s waiting room. She tells every cashier at Target that she loves them, and she means it. She loves purple, and unicorns, and butterflies, and her big brother Owen, who’s nine and lets her win at Candy Land. She loves her daddy’s pancakes and my makeup brushes, which she steals from my bag and uses to paint the cat.
Sending her to first grade was one of the hardest decisions I’d ever made.
She’d done two years of preschool at a special program run by the district, with eight kids in a class and three teachers. She’d thrived there. But this year, her team recommended she go to a regular first-grade classroom at Brookside, our neighborhood school, with an aide to help her part of the day and pull-out sessions for speech and occupational therapy. It’s called inclusion. All the research says it’s best for kids like Victoria. They learn more. They make friends. The other kids learn too.
We sat in a conference room at the district office in June with seven people around the table and wrote her Individualized Education Program. Her IEP, everybody calls it. Twenty-two pages. Goals for reading and math and speech and fine motor skills. An aide for four hours a day. Speech therapy twice a week.
And I worried about everything.
Would the other children make fun of her? Would they stare at her face, at her eyes, at the way she talks? Would she understand if someone was cruel? Would she even know what cruelty was, my daughter who hugs strangers? Would she tell me if something happened?
But Victoria wanted to go to school more than anything. She’d watched Owen get on the bus every morning for four years, and she’d stood at the window in her pajamas with her hands pressed against the glass. All summer long, she wore her new backpack around the house, a purple one with a unicorn on it, even to bed.
For the first two weeks, she was happier than I’d ever seen her.
Every afternoon, she’d come running out of the building into my arms, talking so fast I could barely understand her. About her new friends. About Kenzie, who sat next to her and had a pet hamster named Cheeto. About recess and the slide and the library, where the librarian let her pick two books instead of one. She’d show me the drawings she’d made in class, pulling them out of her unicorn backpack. A rainbow. A cat. Our family, four stick figures holding hands, with me drawn very tall and with enormous hair, which I chose to take as a compliment.
Her teacher was new. A young woman named Miss Price, fresh out of college, her first year teaching. I’d met her for five minutes at open house in August, in a crowded classroom full of parents. She seemed nice. Bright and cheerful, with a high blonde ponytail and a sweater with apples on it. She shook my hand and said she was so excited to have Victoria.
I believed her. I had no reason not to.
## Chapter Three: The Hallway
When I pulled into the parking lot at Brookside, the festival was in full swing. Kids everywhere. Kids on the hay bales, kids in line for the bouncy castle, kids running across the playground with balloons. And so many of them had their faces painted. Tigers and kittens and spiderwebs and rainbows and superhero masks. A little boy ran past me with a green dinosaur on his cheek, roaring.
I went in the side entrance. The front hallway was full of tables and decorations. And there, waiting for me by the trophy case outside the principal’s office, sitting on a little bench with the principal’s hand on her back, was Victoria.
Her face was blotchy and red. Her eyes were swollen. Her pigtails had come half undone. She was holding a tissue in both hands, twisted into a rope.
She spotted me and ran straight into my arms.
“Mommy,” she sobbed into my neck. “I want to go home. I want to go home.”
I held her. I picked her up, all forty-two pounds of her, and held her against my chest, and I looked over her head at Mrs. Whitaker. The principal was a tall woman in her late fifties with short gray hair and reading glasses on a beaded chain. She looked worried and helpless.
“She came in from the gym about twenty-five minutes ago,” Mrs. Whitaker said quietly. “Crying. She won’t tell us what happened. She just keeps saying she wants you.”
I carried Victoria a little way down the hallway, away from the office, near the double doors that led to the gym. Through the doors, I could see the face painting station set up at a long table under a paper banner that said FACE PAINTING! in bubble letters. A young teacher was sitting there with a palette of paint and a cup of brushes, painting butterflies on another little girl’s cheeks. She had a high blonde ponytail. She was laughing with the child in front of her.
There was a line of kids waiting. All girls. Seven or eight of them.
I set Victoria down and knelt beside her on the hallway floor so we were eye to eye.
“Sweetheart,” I said. “What happened? You can tell me.”
She looked at me with her swollen eyes. Then she turned and pointed through the gym doors at the face painting table. At the teacher with the blonde ponytail, whose back was turned to us. Too far away to hear.
“She said makeup is for pretty girls,” Victoria whispered. “And it won’t help me. Because I’m not pretty.”
I couldn’t breathe.
“I was in line,” Victoria said. Her voice was shaking. “With Kenzie. And Kenzie got a butterfly. And when it was my turn, I sat down in the chair. And Miss Price looked at me and said no.” She wiped her nose on her sleeve. “She said, face paint is like makeup, and makeup is for pretty girls. She said it won’t help me because I’m not pretty. And she said go play in the bouncy castle instead.”
I knelt there on the hallway floor of my daughter’s elementary school and felt something go cold and still inside me. Like ice forming on a lake.
Victoria looked up at me. Her chin was trembling.
“Mommy, am I not pretty?” she asked. “Will I never be pretty?” She grabbed my hands. “Please don’t lie to me.”
I wiped her tears with my thumbs. I kissed her forehead, right in the middle, where I always do.
“Victoria,” I said. “You are beautiful, sweetheart. You are the most beautiful girl I have ever seen in my whole life. Don’t ever let anyone tell you otherwise.”
“But Mommy,” she said, and her voice broke. “She’s a teacher. Teachers don’t lie.”
I looked through the gym doors at the young woman with the blonde ponytail. She was still smiling. She’d finished the butterflies and was holding up a hand mirror so the little girl could see. The little girl squealed. The next girl in line climbed up into the chair. Miss Price picked up a brush and started painting a pink heart on her cheek, completely unaware that I was standing there.
And then an idea came to me.
## Chapter Four: The Butterfly Table
“Baby,” I said. “Go back to Mrs. Whitaker, okay? Go sit with her in the office. Tell her Mommy will be there in five minutes. I just need to take care of something.”
Victoria looked at me.
“Are we going home?”
“We’re going to the movies, sweetheart,” I said. “The new unicorn one. And afterward, we’ll get your favorite ice cream. Cotton candy with rainbow sprinkles. I promise.”
She gave me one last hug, a hard one, with her whole body. Then she hurried back down the hallway in her light-up sneakers. I watched until she disappeared into the principal’s office, until I saw Mrs. Whitaker put her hand on Victoria’s back and guide her to a chair.
Then I turned toward the gym.
Miss Price had never met me, except for five minutes at open house in a crowded room. She wouldn’t remember my face. She didn’t know I was Victoria’s mother. And I intended to keep it that way, at least for a few minutes.
Because I wanted to know. I wanted to hear her say it. I wanted to know if my six-year-old daughter had misunderstood something, the way six-year-olds sometimes do. Or if a grown woman, a teacher, had looked at my child and decided she wasn’t worth a butterfly.
So I went straight toward her table as she finished painting the little girl with the pink heart.
I stood at the end of the line. Behind the last little girl. A tall woman in a black theater T-shirt with spirit gum on my fingers and my hair in a messy bun, waiting for a turn at face painting. The little girls in line looked up at me curiously. One of them giggled.
Miss Price finished the pink heart and held up the mirror. The girl ran off. The next one climbed up. I watched her paint a rainbow, then a kitten, then another butterfly. She was good at it. Quick, steady hands. Bright colors. Every girl got the mirror at the end and a little compliment.
“There, gorgeous.”
“Look how pretty you are.”
“Oh, that’s perfect on you, sweetie.”
When the last little girl ran off, I stepped forward.
Miss Price looked up at me, surprised.
“Oh,” she said, and laughed. “Hi! Are you here to help? We could use another painter. The line’s been crazy.”
“Actually,” I said, and I smiled. “I was hoping you’d paint me.”
She laughed again.
“Seriously?”
“Seriously,” I said. I sat down in the little chair. My knees came up almost to my chest. “I’m somebody’s mom. My kid said I should get a butterfly too. I’m a sucker for butterflies.”
“Okay!” she said brightly. She picked up a clean brush. “What colors?”
“Pink and purple,” I said. “And sparkly.”
She dipped the brush in pink and started on my left cheek. Up close, she was even younger than I’d thought. Maybe twenty-three. She had a little cluster of freckles across her nose and pale blue eyes and a tiny silver cross on a chain around her neck.
“Busy morning?” I asked.
“Oh my gosh, so busy,” she said. “I’ve done probably sixty kids. The first graders all wanted butterflies. I don’t think I can paint another butterfly ever again.” She laughed. “Kidding. It’s fun. I love this part.”
“I heard there was a little girl crying earlier,” I said casually. “One of the first graders. I saw her in the hallway on my way in.”
Miss Price’s brush paused for just a second. Then kept going.
“Oh, her,” she said. She made a face. “The Down syndrome girl. Victoria. She’s in my class.”
“What happened?” I asked. “She seemed really upset.”
Miss Price sighed, a long sigh, like she’d been carrying something heavy all morning. She dipped her brush in purple.
“Honestly? I just told her the truth,” she said. “She sat down and wanted a butterfly like the other girls. And I just thought, why? What’s the point? Face paint’s basically makeup. And makeup’s for making pretty girls prettier.” She shrugged one shoulder while she painted. “It’s not going to do anything for her. With her face. You know?”
I didn’t move. I sat perfectly still in that little chair with her brush on my cheek.
“I told her to go play in the bouncy castle instead,” Miss Price said. “I thought I was being nice, honestly. Saving her from being disappointed. Like, why get her hopes up?” She switched brushes and picked up the glitter. “And then she just started crying and ran out of the gym. Kids like that get so emotional.” She laughed a little. “It’s been a whole thing.”
She was sprinkling glitter on my cheek when I saw them.
Standing in the gym doorway, about fifteen feet behind her. Mrs. Whitaker, the principal, with her reading glasses on her chain. And holding her hand, Victoria. With her blotchy face and her half-undone pigtails. She’d gotten worried when I didn’t come back in five minutes. She’d asked Mrs. Whitaker to take her to find me.
They’d heard every word.
## Chapter Five: The Mirror
Miss Price set down the glitter and picked up the hand mirror. She held it up in front of my face with a big smile.
“There!” she said. “Gorgeous!”
I looked in the mirror. A pink and purple butterfly on my left cheek, with sparkles. It was beautiful. She was genuinely talented.
“It’s lovely,” I said. “Thank you.”
I didn’t get up. I sat there in that little chair, looking at my reflection, for a long moment. Then I lowered the mirror and looked at her.
“Miss Price,” I said quietly. “My name is Erin Parker. I’m Victoria’s mother.”
All the color went out of her face.
She stared at me. Her mouth opened and closed. I watched her replay every word she’d just said, in order, inside her head. I watched her understand.
“I…” she said. “Mrs. Parker, I didn’t…”
“Turn around,” I said.
She turned around. And saw her principal standing in the doorway of the gym. And beside her, holding her hand, the little girl in the pink sweater with the sequin heart.
Mrs. Whitaker’s face was like stone. I’ve never seen a person look so angry and so calm at the same time.
“Miss Price,” she said. Very quietly. “Please come to my office. Now. Mrs. Atkins will take over the face painting.”
Miss Price stood up. Her hands were shaking. She put down her brush and her palette. She walked across the gym toward the doorway, with her eyes on the floor, and as she passed Victoria, she didn’t look at her. She couldn’t.
Victoria watched her go. Then she looked at me, sitting in the face-painting chair with a butterfly on my cheek.
“Mommy,” she said. “You got a butterfly.”
“I did,” I said. I held out my arms. “Come here, baby.”
She came. Slowly, at first, then running. I pulled her up onto my lap in that little chair, and she looked at my cheek up close and touched the sparkles with one finger.
“It’s pretty,” she said.
“So are you,” I said.
Then I did the thing I’d come to do.
I set her down in the chair. I stood up and moved around to Miss Price’s side of the table. I picked up the palette. I looked at the brushes in the cup, and I picked the three I wanted. A fine liner. A flat. A round. And then, from the small fanny pack I always wear to work, I took out my own brushes. The good ones. The ones I use on the actors at the theater.
The kids in the gym were starting to notice. A few of the girls who’d already had their faces painted drifted over to watch. Then a few more. Parents too.
I knelt down in front of my daughter.
“Victoria,” I said. “Do you know what Mommy does at work?”
She nodded.
“You make the actors pretty.”
“I make them whatever they need to be,” I said. “Old. Young. Scary. Funny. Kings and queens and ghosts.” I dipped my liner brush in pink. “But I’ve never once in my whole life painted anybody who was more beautiful than you.”
I painted her the most beautiful butterfly I have ever painted in fifteen years of doing this for a living.
It went from her left temple down across her cheekbone, wings spread wide, pink at the center fading to purple at the edges, with fine black veining I drew with the liner brush, the way I’d paint a fairy for a production of *A Midsummer Night’s Dream*. I added little dots of white along the wing edges. I painted a second, smaller butterfly flying up toward her right eyebrow, as if the first one had brought a friend. I gave them both glitter. Lots of glitter. And on the tip of her nose, a tiny purple heart.
It took me eleven minutes. Victoria sat perfectly still the whole time, which she has never done for anything in her life. Her eyes were closed. She was smiling.
When I was done, I held up the mirror.
She opened her eyes. She looked at herself.
She didn’t say anything for a long time. She just looked. Turned her head left and right. Touched the purple heart on her nose.
“Mommy,” she whispered. “Is that me?”
“That’s you,” I said.
She looked for a long time. Then she said, very quietly, “I’m pretty.”
“You’re pretty,” I said. “You were always pretty. The butterflies just came to say so.”
There were about thirty kids around the table by then. And their parents. Somebody’s dad was filming on his phone. And a little girl with a ponytail and a tiger on her cheek stepped forward from the crowd. It was Kenzie, Victoria’s friend, with the hamster named Cheeto.
“Victoria,” Kenzie said. “Yours is the prettiest one.”
Victoria looked at her. Then she smiled so wide her eyes disappeared.
Then another little girl said, “Can I have one like Victoria’s?”
And another. And another. And by the time Mrs. Atkins came over to take over the face painting, there was a line of nineteen little girls and four little boys, all asking for a butterfly like Victoria’s.
## Chapter Six: Ice Cream
We went to the movies. The new unicorn one, at the AMC on Michigan Road, at one-fifteen on a Saturday afternoon. Victoria wouldn’t let me wash her face. She sat in the dark theater with her popcorn in her lap and her butterflies sparkling in the light from the screen, and every few minutes she’d reach up and touch the purple heart on her nose, just to make sure it was still there.
Afterward, we went to Handel’s for ice cream. Cotton candy with rainbow sprinkles. She ate the whole thing, and got sprinkles on her butterfly, and I didn’t care.
In the car on the way home, she was quiet for a long time. Then she said, “Mommy?”
“Yes, baby?”
“Why did Miss Price say I’m not pretty?”
I’d been thinking about how to answer that question since the hallway. I still didn’t know. I gripped the steering wheel.
“I think,” I said slowly, “that Miss Price learned something wrong somewhere. About what pretty means. Somebody taught her a wrong thing a long time ago, and she believed it.”
“Like a wrong answer on a test?”
“Exactly like a wrong answer on a test,” I said.
She thought about that.
“Can she fix it?”
“I hope so,” I said.
That night, after the kids were asleep, I sat at the kitchen table with Chris and told him everything. He listened without interrupting, the way he does. When I got to the part about makeup being for pretty girls, he put his coffee cup down on the table very carefully, and his jaw went tight. When I got to the part where Miss Price said “the Down syndrome girl,” and “kids like that,” and “with her face,” he got up from the table and went out on the back porch and stood there in the dark for ten minutes.
When he came back in, his eyes were red.
“I want her fired,” he said. “I want her out of that school. I want her out of teaching.”
“I know,” I said.
“Erin, she’s six. Victoria’s six. She asked you if she’ll never be pretty.”
“I know, Chris.”
He sat back down. He put his face in his hands.
“What did you say to her?” he asked. “When she asked.”
“I said she was beautiful,” I said. “And then I painted her the best butterfly I’ve ever painted in my life, in front of the whole first grade.”
He looked up at me. Then he laughed, a broken, tired laugh.
“Of course you did,” he said. “Of course you did.”
## Chapter Seven: The Meeting
Mrs. Whitaker called me Sunday night at home. She apologized for calling on a weekend. She said she hadn’t slept.
“Mrs. Parker,” she said. “I want you to know Miss Price has been placed on administrative leave, effective immediately. She won’t be in the classroom on Monday. We have a long-term substitute coming. Mrs. Delgado. She has twenty-two years of experience, including special education.”
“Thank you,” I said.
“And I’d like to meet with you and your husband,” she said. “This week. With the district’s director of special education. To talk about what happens next. For Victoria.” She paused. “And about Miss Price.”
We met on Wednesday morning at the district office on Third Avenue, in the same conference room where we’d written Victoria’s IEP in June. Mrs. Whitaker was there. And Dr. Ramona Ellis, the director of special education, a small, sharp woman in her sixties with silver hair who’d worked in the district for thirty years. And the district’s human resources director, a man named Gary Kessler, with a yellow legal pad and a pen he kept clicking.
Chris and I sat on one side of the long table. They sat on the other.
Dr. Ellis spoke first. She said the district was deeply sorry. She said what happened to Victoria was a violation of everything the district believed in and everything it was required to do under the law. Victoria’s IEP, she explained, along with a federal law called Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, guaranteed that Victoria would be included in every school activity on the same basis as every other child. Including the Fall Festival. Including face painting.
“What Miss Price did,” Dr. Ellis said, “excluded your daughter from a school activity because of her disability. And humiliated her in front of her classmates. That’s not just unkind, Mrs. Parker. It’s discrimination.”
“We talked to a lawyer,” Chris said quietly. “On Monday. A friend of my brother’s. She said we could file a complaint with the Office for Civil Rights. In Chicago. At the Department of Education.”
Mr. Kessler stopped clicking his pen.
“You can,” Dr. Ellis said. She didn’t look surprised. She didn’t look defensive. “That’s your right. And I want you to know that if you do, the district will cooperate fully. We won’t fight it. We’ll tell them exactly what happened.” She folded her hands on the table. “But I’d like to hear what you want first. Because I think you came here wanting something specific.”
I looked at her. She was right. I had.
“I want Victoria in Mrs. Delgado’s class,” I said. “Permanently. Not Miss Price’s. Ever.”
Dr. Ellis wrote it down.
“Done,” she said.
“I want every teacher at Brookside to have training,” I said. “Not a pamphlet. Real training. From somebody who knows. About disability. About inclusion. About what words do to kids.” I took a breath. “I’d like it to be from the Down Syndrome Indiana organization. They do it for other districts. I called them yesterday.”
“Done,” Dr. Ellis said. “Before winter break. I’ll make it mandatory for the whole district, not just Brookside.”
“And Miss Price,” Chris said.
The room went quiet.
Mr. Kessler cleared his throat. He explained that Miss Price was a first-year teacher on a probationary contract. That under Indiana law, the district could decide not to renew her contract at the end of the year for almost any reason. That there was an investigation. That depending on what it found, the district could terminate her now, or reassign her, or put her on an improvement plan.
“What do you want to happen to her, Mrs. Parker?” Dr. Ellis asked.
I’d thought about this for four days. I’d lain awake thinking about it. About a young woman with a silver cross around her neck, painting butterflies on sixty children and telling my daughter she wasn’t worth one. About the way she said “kids like that.” About the way she said she thought she was being nice.
“I want to know why,” I said finally. “Before I decide anything. I want to know why a twenty-three-year-old woman who chose to become a first-grade teacher would say that to a six-year-old.”
Dr. Ellis looked at me for a long moment.
“That’s a fair question,” she said. “She’s asked to write you a letter. Would you read it?”
## Chapter Eight: Madison
The letter came the next week, in a plain white envelope through the district office. Four handwritten pages on lined notebook paper. Chris didn’t want to read it. I read it alone, at the kitchen table, after the kids were asleep.
Dear Mrs. Parker, it began. I don’t expect you to forgive me. I don’t think I would, if I were you. But you asked why. So I’m going to tell you the truth, even though it’s the most embarrassing thing I’ve ever written.
Her name was Madison Price. She grew up in a small town in southern Indiana, near Jasper. Her mother was a pageant mom. Not the ones on television, she wrote, but close. Madison was in her first beauty pageant at three years old. Little Miss Dubois County. By the time she was nine, she’d competed in thirty-one of them.
My mother used to put makeup on me every morning before school, from the time I was five, she wrote. She told me makeup was for pretty girls. She said pretty girls get everything and ugly girls get nothing. She said it so many times I believed it was a fact, like two plus two.
When Madison was ten, she broke her nose falling off her bike. It healed crooked. Her mother stopped entering her in pageants. She started entering Madison’s little sister instead.
She stopped doing my makeup, Madison wrote. She said there wasn’t any point anymore. She said makeup can’t fix some faces. She said it at the kitchen table, in front of my sister. I was ten.
I put the letter down on the kitchen table for a while. Then I picked it back up.
When I sat down at that face painting table, she wrote, I wasn’t thinking. I was just painting. And Victoria sat down in front of me, and she was so happy, and I looked at her face, and I heard my mother’s voice come out of my mouth. Word for word. Makeup is for pretty girls. It won’t help you. I didn’t even know I was going to say it until I said it.
And then you sat down in that chair, and you asked me about her, and I said it again. Worse. To a stranger. Because I’d spent the whole morning telling myself I’d been nice to her. That I’d saved her from disappointment. Because that’s what my mother told me she was doing for me, when she stopped.
I’m so sorry. I’m sorry for what I said to Victoria. I’m sorry for what I said to you. I’m sorry that the first time your daughter asked if she was pretty, it was because of me. I became a teacher because I wanted to be the kind of grown-up I never had. And on the first big day of my first year, I turned into my mother.
I’ve resigned. I gave my letter to Mr. Kessler today. I don’t think I should be in a classroom right now. Maybe not ever. I’ve started seeing a counselor. I’m trying to understand how a thing I hated so much got so far inside me that it came out of my mouth without asking.
If there’s ever anything I can do for Victoria, please tell me. Even if it’s just staying away from her forever. I’ll do that too.
Madison Price.
At the bottom, after her name, she’d added one more line, smaller.
P.S. You were right. Victoria’s butterfly was the most beautiful one in the gym.
I sat at that kitchen table for a long time with the letter in my hands.
Then I did something I didn’t expect to do. I cried. Not for Victoria, this time. For a ten-year-old girl in a small town in southern Indiana, sitting at a kitchen table while her mother said there wasn’t any point anymore.
## Chapter Nine: Mirror Mornings
Victoria had nightmares for two weeks after the festival.
She’d wake up crying at two in the morning, and when I went in, she’d be sitting up in bed with Mr. Wiggles, her stuffed unicorn, held tight against her chest. She couldn’t always say what the dream was. Once, she said there was a lady who wouldn’t let her in the bouncy castle. Once, she said she looked in the mirror and her face was gone.
So I started something. Every morning before school, I’d take her into the bathroom and stand her on her little step stool in front of the big mirror over the sink. And we’d look at her face together.
“What do you see?” I’d ask.
At first, she’d shrug.
“Me.”
“Tell me about you,” I’d say. “One thing that’s beautiful.”
The first morning, she couldn’t think of anything. She just stood there on her stool looking at herself in her purple unicorn pajamas with her lip trembling. So I went first.
“Your eyes,” I said. “Look at them. See how they turn up at the corners? Like you’re always about to laugh. Daddy says they’re the happiest eyes he’s ever seen.”
She looked at her eyes in the mirror for a long time.
The next morning she said, “My eyes.” The morning after that, “My eyes and my pigtails.” The morning after that, she said, “My smile. Because it’s big.”
By the end of October, she was doing it by herself. She’d climb up on her stool before I even got to the bathroom and stand there and talk to her reflection. I’d stand in the hallway and listen.
“Good morning, Victoria,” she’d say to the mirror. “You have happy eyes. You have a big smile. You have pigtails. You are pretty. Have a good day.”
Then she’d climb down and go get her unicorn backpack.
Mrs. Delgado turned out to be wonderful. She was fifty-four and had taught first grade for twenty-two years, the last eight in an inclusion classroom, and she ran her room like a big, warm, slightly chaotic family. She had a class pet, a bearded dragon named Sir Reginald. She had a reading corner with beanbag chairs and a lamp shaped like a mushroom. On Victoria’s first day in her class, she called me at home that evening.
“Mrs. Parker,” she said. “I just wanted you to know. Victoria told every child in my class that her mommy paints butterflies on actors. They think she’s famous.” She laughed. “Also, she told Sir Reginald he was pretty. He seemed to appreciate it.”
In November, Down Syndrome Indiana came to Brookside and did the training. All forty-one teachers and aides, in the library, on a Wednesday afternoon. Two hours. Mrs. Whitaker sent me the outline. The person who led it was a twenty-eight-year-old woman named Bethany Coles, who has Down syndrome herself, and works as an advocate for the organization, and gave a talk to the teachers called “What I Wish My Teachers Had Known.”
Mrs. Whitaker told me afterward that half the teachers in the room were crying by the end.
## Chapter Ten: The Question
In February, a week after Victoria’s seventh birthday, I got a call from Mrs. Whitaker.
“Mrs. Parker,” she said. “I have an unusual request. And I want you to know that you can say no.”
Madison Price had called her. She’d spent the winter working at a coffee shop in Bloomington and seeing her counselor twice a week. She’d started volunteering on Saturday mornings with an adaptive dance program for kids with disabilities, run by Indiana University. She wanted to know if she could apologize to Victoria. In person. Once. With Mrs. Whitaker there and me there and anybody else I wanted there.
“She said she understands if you say no,” Mrs. Whitaker said. “She said she’ll never ask again. But she said she can’t stop thinking about Victoria believing what she said. And she wants to tell her, herself, that it wasn’t true.”
I didn’t answer right away.
“Can I think about it?” I asked.
“Of course.”
I thought about it for a week. Chris didn’t want it. He said it was for Madison, not for Victoria. That it would only open the wound again. That Victoria was finally okay and we should leave it alone.
Maybe he was right. I didn’t know.
So I did what I should have done in the first place. I asked Victoria.
We were in the bathroom on a Saturday morning. Mirror time. She was on her stool. I was behind her, brushing her hair into pigtails.
“Victoria,” I said. “Do you remember Miss Price?”
Her face changed in the mirror. Just a little. A flicker.
“She said I’m not pretty,” she said quietly.
“She did,” I said. “And it wasn’t true. And she knows it wasn’t true now. She wants to come and tell you she’s sorry. Would you like that? Or would you rather not?”
Victoria looked at herself in the mirror for a long time. At her happy eyes. At her big smile, which wasn’t smiling right then. At her half-finished pigtails.
“Is she still sad?” she asked finally.
I didn’t expect that question.
“I think she is,” I said. “I think she’s been very sad for a long time. Even before she said that to you.”
Victoria thought about it.
“Can she get a butterfly?” she asked.
I stared at her in the mirror.
“If she says sorry,” Victoria said, very seriously, “can I paint her a butterfly? So she’s not sad anymore?”
## Chapter Eleven: Sorry
Madison Price came to our house on a Sunday afternoon in March.
Mrs. Whitaker came too. And Chris. He’d changed his mind when I told him what Victoria asked. He said he still didn’t like it. He said he’d be right there. He stood in the kitchen doorway with his arms crossed the whole time.
Madison looked different. Her blonde hair was cut short, to her chin. She wore jeans and a plain gray sweater and no makeup at all. She was still wearing the little silver cross. She stood on our front porch holding a small wrapped box and looking like she might be sick.
I opened the door.
“Mrs. Parker,” she said. “Thank you. For letting me come.”
“Come in,” I said.
Victoria was in the living room, sitting on the floor by the coffee table. She’d set it up herself. My makeup kit from the theater, open, with all the brushes laid out in a row. A cup of water. The pink and purple paint. The glitter. Her face was bare. She’d asked me not to paint her today.
She looked up when Madison came in. And for a second, I saw her flinch. Just a little.
Madison saw it too. She stopped in the middle of the living room. She didn’t come any closer.
Then she knelt down on the carpet. All the way down, on both knees, about six feet away from my daughter, so they were eye to eye. The same way I’d knelt in the hallway at Brookside.
“Victoria,” she said. Her voice was shaking. “Do you remember me?”
Victoria nodded.
“I said something to you at the festival,” Madison said. “When you sat down at my table. I said makeup was for pretty girls, and it wouldn’t help you, because you weren’t pretty.” She swallowed. “I need to tell you something. It was a lie. It was the worst lie I ever told. You are pretty. You were pretty that day. You’re pretty right now.”
Victoria looked at her.
“Then why did you say it?” Victoria asked.
Madison’s eyes filled with tears.
“Because when I was a little girl,” she said, “a grown-up said it to me. My mommy. And I believed her. And I carried it around inside me for a long time, like a rock in my shoe. And when I saw you, I just took the rock out and threw it at you.” She wiped her eyes. “That wasn’t fair. You didn’t do anything wrong. You just wanted a butterfly.”
Victoria looked at her for a long, long time. The whole room was quiet. Chris in the doorway. Mrs. Whitaker on the couch. Me in the armchair.
Then Victoria picked up a brush from the coffee table.
“Come here,” she said.
Madison stared at her.
“What?”
“Come here,” Victoria said again, very firmly, the voice she uses on the cat. “Sit down. I’m going to paint you.”
Madison looked at me. I nodded.
She crawled across our living room carpet on her knees and sat down cross-legged in front of my seven-year-old daughter, beside the coffee table. Victoria dipped the brush in pink. She held it up. She looked at Madison’s face very carefully, the way I do when I’m studying an actor.
“Close your eyes,” she said.
Madison closed her eyes.
Victoria painted her a butterfly. On her left cheek, the same place I painted mine in the gym. It wasn’t a very good butterfly. The wings were lopsided and one was much bigger than the other, and the pink and the purple ran together, and she got some paint in Madison’s hair. She added glitter. A lot of glitter. Then, very carefully, with her tongue sticking out the side of her mouth, she painted a tiny purple heart on the tip of Madison’s nose. Slightly crooked. Exactly where her nose had been broken when she was ten.
When she was done, she picked up the hand mirror off the coffee table and held it up in front of Madison’s face.
“There,” Victoria said. “Now you’re pretty too.”
Madison opened her eyes. She looked in the mirror.
And she broke. She put both hands over her face, butterfly and all, and she sobbed. Right there on our living room carpet, in front of all of us. Big, gulping sobs, the kind that come from a long way down, from a kitchen table in a small town when she was ten years old.
Victoria put down the mirror. She looked worried. She looked at me.
“Mommy,” she said. “Did I do it wrong?”
“No, baby,” I said. My own voice wasn’t working right. “You did it exactly right.”
Victoria looked back at Madison, crying into her hands. Then she scooted across the carpet and put her arms around her. Around her neck, hard, with her whole body, the way she hugs everybody. The way she hugs strangers at Target.
“It’s okay,” Victoria said into Madison’s shoulder. “You’re pretty. I promise. I don’t lie.”
In the kitchen doorway, Chris turned around and went out on the back porch. Mrs. Whitaker had her glasses off and was wiping her eyes with a tissue.
Before she left, Madison gave Victoria the little wrapped box. Victoria tore the paper off. Inside was a set of face paints. Professional ones, in a tin, sixteen colors. And a little card in Madison’s handwriting.
For Victoria. For painting people who need it.
## Chapter Twelve: The Next Festival
The next Fall Festival at Brookside Elementary was on a Saturday in October, a year and a week after the first one.
Victoria woke me up at five-thirty. She climbed onto the bed in her purple pajamas and sat on my stomach, which at seven and a half is about forty-nine pounds of pure determination.
“Mommy,” she said. “It’s festival day. Get up. We have to set up.”
We’d volunteered. Both of us. Mrs. Whitaker had asked me in September if I’d run the face painting station this year, and I’d said yes, on one condition. That I’d have a partner.
So at eight-thirty, there we were, at a long table under the paper banner in the gym that said FACE PAINTING! in bubble letters. Me, in my black theater T-shirt with my good brushes. And beside me, on a booster seat, in her pink sweater with the sequin heart, my daughter. With her tin of sixteen professional face paints from Madison open in front of her. And a hand-lettered sign taped to the front of her side of the table, which she’d made herself with markers.
VICTORIA’S BUTTERFLYS. EVERYBODY IS PRETTY.
She’d spelled butterflies wrong. Neither of us cared.
The line was long. Kids everywhere. Mrs. Delgado’s class came first, and every one of them wanted Victoria. Not me. Victoria. Kenzie got a butterfly. A little boy named Mateo got a butterfly. A girl in a wheelchair from the third grade, whose name was Grace, got the biggest butterfly Victoria could paint, and sat there afterward holding the mirror and grinning.
Victoria’s butterflies were still lopsided. They still ran together. She still got paint in people’s hair. And every single time, when she was done, she held up the hand mirror and said the same thing.
“There. Now you’re pretty too.”
Around eleven, I looked up from painting a dragon on a fourth grader’s face and saw a young woman standing at the back of Victoria’s line. Short blonde hair, to her chin. Jeans and a gray sweater. A little silver cross around her neck. Holding the hand of a small boy in leg braces, about five years old, with a big gap-toothed smile.
Madison.
She’d written me in August. She was teaching again, she said. Not in a regular classroom. At a preschool in Bloomington for kids with disabilities. She’d gone back to school at night for her special education license. She said she had a student named Eli who’d heard all about Victoria’s butterflies, and could they come to the festival. I’d said yes.
When they got to the front of the line, Victoria looked up from her paints. She saw Madison. Her face lit up.
“Miss Price!” she said.
“Hi, Victoria,” Madison said. She knelt down beside the table. “This is my friend Eli. He’s five. He’s in my class. He wants a butterfly.”
Victoria looked at Eli. At his leg braces, and his gap-toothed smile, and his thick glasses. She looked at him the way she looks at everybody. Like he was the most interesting person in the whole gym.
“Sit down, Eli,” she said. “I’m going to paint you the best one.”
She painted him a butterfly. Lopsided. Glittery. With a purple heart on the tip of his nose. When she held up the mirror, Eli looked at himself and laughed out loud, a big delighted laugh that filled up the whole gym.
“There,” Victoria told him. “Now you’re pretty too.”
Then she looked up at Madison, still kneeling beside the table.
“Miss Price,” she said. “Do you want one? You’re sad again. I can tell.”
Madison laughed. Then she didn’t. Her eyes filled up. She sat down in the little chair, the same little chair, and closed her eyes. And my daughter picked up her brush and painted her teacher a butterfly, right there in front of the whole festival, with her tongue sticking out the side of her mouth.
I watched them from my side of the table, with a dragon half-finished on a fourth grader’s face, and I didn’t say anything. I didn’t have to.
Because I used to think beauty was something I gave people, with my brushes and my paints and my fifteen years of training. I put it on the actors every night at the theater and took it off with cold cream every morning. But that year, my daughter taught me something no stage ever did. Beauty isn’t something you paint onto a face. It’s something one person decides to see in another, and then says out loud, so they can hear it.
Victoria held up the mirror.
“There,” she said to the young woman who once told her she’d never be pretty. “Now you’re pretty too.”




